racism 101: bule prices

The bule tax is one of Indonesia's worst kept secrets. As an expat, I generally pay more for things than my Indonesian friends. It is most apparent when you rent a house or apartment, which is why this time I decided to stay out of it and let Awan find a place for us.

It paid off, but the real estate agent is not happy. She has finally figured out that a bule is the ultimate tenant and responded by increasing the rent by 20%! Luckily for me, the agent has fairly loose morals, and is stiffing the agency that is employing her. My response: if you like your job --- and working generally --- you will honour the deal.

But I am not happy about having to blackmail someone just to be treated fairly. That sucks. Why should I be forced to compromise my integrity? The bule tax is horrible. It is extremely unfair. There are lots of reasons given for the bule tax, but they are all basically bullshit:
  • expats do not earn more than Indonesians --- at Rouse, skill and experience determines salary, and not skin colour
  • look around you people, the truly rich people in this country are Indonesians!
  • most expats in Indonesia are doing exactly what Indonesian foreign workers are doing --- they are sending money to support their families back home
  • charging a higher price on the basis of a person's skin colour is racist
  • charging expats more is opportunistic --- it is taking advantage of people who don't know how to negotiate or don't know what is fair
  • the fact that the bule tax is common knowledge does not make it okay! 
I am lucky because I have Awan to help me get a fair deal, but most expats don't. They know they are being charged too much, but let it happen, because what can you do? That is sick! 

I am not asking for much: just treat people fairly and with respect. 
Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (13)

Jul 26, 2009
b4bigirl said...
that's sucks...
they thought that bule have more money and everything..
Jul 26, 2009
 said...
I'm with you Brett, my bosses are Taiwan and Singaporean aaand I got pissed off with similar issues. As an Indonesian, I'm terribly sorry for what had happened to you. Hope all Indonesians learn something from this
Jul 27, 2009
litz said...
Well, as an Indonesian I'm not proud for what most of Indonesian did. so, what are you going to do? just cant change that and wont be easy too.
But considering you've been lived here for a while, I think you already know how to get away with the white man tax eventhough not much....
Jul 27, 2009
Rob said...
Mate, I did not know whether to laugh or feel for you on this one. Even after the time you have spent living in Indonesia it is interesting that this still gets you going. It is enlightening that you have learned that it is always going to be easier to get your Indonesian half to do the bargaining / negotiating for places to live and other big ticket items.

The really interesting part is that the landlady still wanted to jack up the rent 20% after finding out you were ultimately the renter. Most Indonesians I have run across generally just go, "bugger", and accept that they got worked over by someone in the know.

On the salary front. I could not agree more. I did not work under an expat agreement. I earned a local salary and there were no additional facilities outside of those that are available for ordinary Indonesian workers (basic health care, and a thirteen month of salary or THR). As a result we lived in the suburbs and rented a place for about IDR 1.2 million / month.

The bule tax as you call it is racist (I think the word bule is racist, but that's just me) as the colour of your skin determines the cost. A lot of expats do well, but the reality is that there are lots of regular Indonesians in the business community doing much better.

So, when do you move?

Jul 27, 2009
Brett McGuire said...
It was the gall (sp?) of the stupid cow even trying it on. We duped her at her own game, she should have admitted defeat gracefully instead of being so bloody stupid to think that I was going to put up with this kind of crap. We are moving right now (apparently). Tomorrow is the official day. Thanks for your support. I agree the word bule is racist.
Jul 27, 2009
john said...
Sometimes it's nice to have clouds.
Jul 27, 2009
john said...
On the serious side I would like to know what the agent was up to with her employer. Agents here are feral and ruthless. What will happen to your 10 million a month (say) deposit over the next year - I mean it will earn about 500 000 rupes for someone. In Oz I believe the renter might be entitled to that interest.
Jul 27, 2009
Brett McGuire said...
clouds...?
Jul 27, 2009
john said...
awan = cloud. I hope Ive got that right. Otherwide "berawan" on the front page of Kompas everyday must mean smog.
Jul 27, 2009
Brett McGuire said...
The 12 months rental (which you have to pay upfront) will be paid directly to the landlord. It's 25% more than 10 mill a month. The agent gets 6 mill commission. Not bad!
Jul 27, 2009
Brett McGuire said...
aaahhh... actually, it's short for kurniawan, which means gift.
Jul 29, 2009
mmport80 said...
wtf? most bule earn more than the av indonesian in indo, of course ppl are gonna charge u more!
Jul 29, 2009
Brett McGuire said...
Most bules pay tax --- so we pay more anyway!

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter



 

About

A hyper-opinionated bule with a deep fondness for Indonesia. Mildly outraged but mostly harmless.

HAKItree
HAKItree blog